Prosperous Period for US Billionaires: Why the System Sustains Income Disparity
To numerous Americans, the financial landscape over the last half-decade has been challenging. Prices have escalated while pay remains unchanged. High mortgage rates have made buying a home a grim prospect. The jobless rate has been creeping up.
The majority of individuals have reported they're putting off major life decisions, including having kids or changing careers, because of financial volatility. But for a very small group of people, the last five years couldn't have been more prosperous.
The Billionaire Boom
The fortune of the world's billionaires increased 54% in 2020, at the peak of the pandemic. And even amid all the financial uncertainty, the stock market has only continued to grow. This growth has largely benefited just a small number of Americans: 10% of the population holds 93% of stock market wealth.
Despite the imbalance as this allocation seems, it's the economic framework working as it is existing today.
"Affluent individuals have bought their jets, they've acquired their multiple houses and mansions, but now they're buying senators and media outlets," explained wealth disparity expert Chuck Collins. "We're now stepping into this other chapter of hyper-extraction where the wealthy are exploiting the system of inequality."
Mapping Economic Classes
To help others grasp what exactly it means to be "rich" in the US, Collins utilizes a concept from journalist Robert Frank who, in a 2007 book on the rich, conceptualized the different levels of wealth as "Affluencia" villages: Wealth Borough, Lower Richistan, Middle Richistan, Upper Richistan and Billionaireville.
To contemporize the concept, Collins categorizes these "wealth villages" based on income levels:
- At the foundation, Affluent Town, are the 10 million Americans who have a household income of at least $110,000 and an overall wealth of over $1.5m.
- The villages get more exclusive as wealth goes up: Lower Richistan has 2.6 million households who have wealth between $6m and $13m.
- Middle Richistan has 1.3 million households who have assets worth an average of $37m.
- Upper Richistan, made up of 130,000 Americans (roughly the size of a small city) has between $60m to $1bn in wealth.
In total, the residents of these villages make up the top 10% of the wealth income distribution, about 14 million Americans altogether, though their experiences vary dramatically.
"You could be in Lower Richistan, and you're still flying in the coach section of a commercial plane," Collins said. "Whereas in Upper Richistan, you're traveling via a private jet. That's a really different cultural experience. You fly private, you have no stakes in the commercial aviation system. You don't care if the whole system shuts down – you're set."
The Billionaireville Effect
The peak in "Richistan" is Billionaireville, which is made up of about 800 American billionaires who are some of the world's richest. The power that this group has substantially outweighs those who are simply well-off, let alone the average American who doesn't inhabit "Richistan" at all.
But Collins thinks the political catchphrase "end extreme wealth" fails to address the core issue and has a "whiff of exterminism" to it.
"It's the distinction between individual behaviors and a system of rules," Collins said. "We should be focused on an economic system that channels so much wealth upward to the billionaires."
Wealth Accumulation Mechanisms
To understand how wealth at the billionaire level works, Collins breaks it down into four parts: acquiring fortune, defending the wealth, political capture and maximum resource extraction.
When many Americans think about wealth, they usually think solely about the first step, Collins said. People can create a modest amount of wealth through creating or operating a successful business, which could get them membership in Affluent Town.
But getting to Billionaireville requires significant resources and strategy in those next three steps. Collins describes what he calls the "wealth defense industry": the tax lawyers, accountants and wealth managers who use their expertise to ensure that the super rich are being calculated about their taxes.
"Wealth defense professionals use a broad range of tools such as trusts, international accounts, secret corporations, non-profit organizations and other vehicles to hold assets," he details.
Political Influence and Hyper-Extraction
To enhance a wealth defense strategy, a family needs government backing. Wealth of over $40m converts to political power, Collins says, and can be used to defend wealth and protect its accumulation.
The ultimate step is a different kind of wealth accumulation, one that Collins calls "extreme removal" to describe how the wealthy have come to influence nearly every single part of an Americans' daily existence largely through private equity, which allows wealthy individuals to support private companies.
"Private equity is searching for those corners of the economy where they can increase profits a little bit harder," Collins said. "One thing I don't think people comprehend is these billionaire private-equity funds are what happens when so much wealth is parked in so few hands, and they can basically shift and say, 'Where else can we extract profits out of the economy?' Healthcare? Great. Mobile home parks? These people can't go anywhere, [so] you can boost their expenses."
Tangible Effects
The consequences of this inequality go beyond the wealth getting wealthier. It's about people paying more for their healthcare, rent and vet bills without seeing any meaningful wage increases. And Collins said the hardship and discontent of this kind of society can lead to profound dissatisfaction.
"The most powerful oligarchs understand people are being marginalized [and] are monetarily hurting," Collins said, adding that conservative politicians have been good at accessing a potent "false common-man appeal".
Policy Situation
The paradox, Collins points out in his book, is that political leaders have appointed a series of billionaires to government roles. Along with tech billionaires who had temporary but significant roles overseeing substantial reductions to the federal workforce, other crucial appointments for commerce, treasury, education and the interior are also all billionaires.
This government structure, along with help from congressional allies, helped pass major tax legislation, which will make lasting reductions for the wealthy and corporations.
The Path Forward
While legislative bodies continue to argue that immigration and unfavorable commercial treaties are the source of everyone's economic problems, "the challenge is: Will the other major party, which has also been controlled by the billionaires and big money, be able to seriously confront the underlying harms?" Collins said.
Progressive politicians, he argues, know what policies are needed to "alter economic flow", including significant reforms to the tax system, increasing the minimum wage and supporting labor organizations.
"It was so, so close, and the law really did embody the will of the most of people who really want lawmakers to solve some of these critical challenges," Collins said. "Elite control is not about developing so much as stopping. It's easier to block than it is to make something significant occur, but the muscle memory is there. We know what that looks like."
Collins is hopeful that there can be change, but said it would require ongoing legislative effort.
"It may be quickly that the pendulum swings back, and then it really is about maintaining a continuous public campaign to make progress on this profound imbalance we're living in," he said. "We can fix this. It is addressable."